To get Pie Insurance loss runs or Next Insurance loss runs, start with the insured. Both carriers sell small business coverage online, so the policy account usually belongs to the business owner, not to a broker. A broker taking over the account gets the report fastest with a signed letter of authority, a list of every policy term, and a request sent through the channel the carrier publishes. Plan on about 10 business days and chase on day 3, 7 and 14.
Already hold a loss run from an online carrier? Test the reader on it, no account needed.
Why online carriers are slower for a broker
With a traditional carrier, the agent of record can pull a loss run from a policy screen. Online carriers flip that. The insured clicked through a quote, paid by card and now holds a login that the broker has never seen. When that insured later asks you to market the account, nobody at the carrier has you on file, and a request from an unknown sender is treated as a data request that needs proof of authority.
That is the same pattern as other carriers that sell direct, such as Hiscox loss runs for small professional liability and general liability accounts. Specialty carriers routed through wholesalers, such as Great American, add a different wrinkle, because the wholesaler holds the file. For direct carriers the fix is the same: paper the authority first, then ask.
A request plan for Pie, Next and similar carriers
| Step | What to do | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ask the insured which policies they bought and when | Online accounts often renew year to year with no broker, so terms are easy to miss |
| 2 | Get a letter of authority signed by the named insured | Without it the carrier will not release claim data to you |
| 3 | Ask the insured to request from their own account in parallel | The owner login is often the quickest route |
| 4 | Send your written request with policy numbers and periods | Naming the numbers avoids a reply asking which policy you mean |
| 5 | Ask for a currently valued report | Most markets reject a report valued more than 60 to 90 days ago |
| 6 | Follow up on day 3, 7 and 14 | A silent request is the usual cause of a missed renewal date |
For wording you can paste, use the loss run request letter, and see how to request loss runs from any carrier for the follow-up schedule.
What small accounts send back
Reports from online carriers are usually short. A restaurant or a contractor with one location may show two or three claims over five years. The risk is not the length, it is the mix. A five-year history for one insured can arrive as three PDFs from three carriers, one of them an online carrier that exported the report as an image. Someone then retypes rows into a spreadsheet, and a transposed digit moves the loss ratio.
Here is how a five-year history looks once it is in one table. The insured is fictional and all amounts are illustrative.
| Policy year | Carrier | Claims | Incurred |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021-22 | Local carrier | 1 | $9,500 |
| 2022-23 | Local carrier | 0 | $0 |
| 2023-24 | Online carrier A | 2 | $14,200 |
| 2024-25 | Online carrier B | 1 | $3,100 |
| 2025-26 | Online carrier B | 0 | $0 |
| Five years | 4 | $26,800 |
An underwriter reading this wants one view across all three carriers, which is why an account that moved between carriers needs the reports read into one claims schema. The difference between the layouts is covered in the loss run report example.
Tracking small accounts without a spreadsheet
One online-carrier request is easy. Forty at renewal season is not. Agencies that handle many small accounts lose time to the chase, not the reading: who has signed, who has been asked, who is overdue. The same discipline applies to any recurring check that has to happen on time, for instance watching a vendor page with a change monitor like Websitechange, where the point is not to look manually every day. For loss runs, the tracking approach is in loss run tracking software for insurance agencies.
Common mistakes with direct-sold policies
- Asking only for the current term. An online policy that renewed three times is three terms, and the report may split them. Request each period by name.
- Skipping the named insured. The letter of authority must be signed by the business owner on the policy, not by an office manager who has no authority to release records.
- Accepting a screenshot. A screenshot of a claims page has no valuation date and no policy number. Ask for the formal loss run so the new market accepts it.
- Waiting past day 7 in silence. Online service teams are small. A second message with the original date and the authority attached usually moves it.
Where LossRunReports fits
LossRunReports sends the request with the client's e-signed authorization, follows up on day 3, 7 and 14, reads each returned report into one claims table and builds the five-year summary. The Broker plan is $299 a month, see pricing. For a team that serves many small accounts, loss run software for small insurance agencies explains how that scales. Carrier rules on records change, so confirm the current channel on the carrier's own site before you send.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get Pie Insurance loss runs?
Ask the insured to request them from their policy account, or send a written request with the insured's signed letter of authority, policy numbers and periods to the channel Pie publishes. Allow about 10 business days and follow up on day 3, 7 and 14.
How do I get Next Insurance loss runs?
The same route applies. The business owner holds the online account, so a broker needs a letter of authority signed by the named insured. Name every policy term, because online policies often renew yearly without a broker involved.
Can a new broker request loss runs from an online carrier?
Yes, with a letter of authority signed by the named insured. Without it, most carriers will only release claim data to the insured.
How far back should the request go?
Five years plus the current term is the usual standard for commercial submissions. See how many years of loss runs a submission needs.
Run your next renewal through LossRunReports and stop chasing online carriers by hand.